Blackening brass problem - Metal Work, Soldering and Metal

I've run into a problem blackening some brass parts. I've done it hundreds of times before without a problem. Sand or file the pieces, pickle in vinegar for an hour and rinse. Soak in Acetone for an hour and rinse. Put in 1:5 dilute Blacken-It for an hour. There is a reaction, but the result is a

James Stanley - I made a brass box

Black Oxide Coating: A Complete Guide to Precision Machined Finish

Weller Soldering Brass Sponge Tip Cleaner (5-Piece) WLACCBS-02

Church Brasswork

soldering brass

Blackening revisited - Metal Work, Soldering and Metal Fittings

Solder doesnt stick (with flux) : r/soldering

soldering brass

Dtydtpe Kitchen Accessories Wire Tip with Brass Cleaner No Iron

Do soldering iron normally goes this black? : r/AskElectronics

Photoetch brass black problems - Metal Work, Soldering and Metal